Translate page with Google

Story Publication logo May 30, 2020

Pressure Mounts Over Calls for Guantánamo’s Most Isolated Prisoners

The entrance to Camp 1 in Guantanamo Bay's Camp Delta. The base's detention camps are numbered based on the order in which they were built, not their order of precedence or level of security. Photo by Kathleen T. Rhem. Cuba, 2018. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Carol Rosenberg tells both big-sweep and incremental stories about the court and captives at...

A prisoner at Guantánamo Bay. Lawyers are seeking to contact their clients there while the pandemic keeps them from traveling to the base. Image by Doug Mills / The New York Times. United States, undated.
A prisoner at Guantánamo Bay. Lawyers are seeking to contact their clients there while the pandemic keeps them from traveling to the base. Image by Doug Mills / The New York Times. United States, undated.

WASHINGTON—With the coronavirus pandemic further isolating the prison at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, the Trump administration is coming under increasing pressure to find ways to let the most isolated men among the 40 wartime prisoners communicate with their lawyers.

Only one of the five men accused of plotting the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks has so far been able to speak with his lawyer during the pandemic, through a special video link between a Pentagon building outside Washington and the courtroom at Guantánamo.

Then on Friday, a federal judge ordered the Justice Department to report back in 30 days on how another prisoner — a Somali man who has never been charged with a crime — could hold a classified phone call with his lawyer.

Judge Reggie B. Walton of the United States District Court in Washington set the deadline in a status conference by telephone in the case of Guled Hassan Duran, 46, a Somali man, who is seeking release through a federal habeas corpus petition. Mr. Duran, who is identified in military records as Gouled Hassan Dourad, was captured in Djibouti in 2004 and has been at Guantánamo since 2006.

Politico quoted the judge as telling the government lawyers that if there is no way to hold classified phone calls, “the government may have to bring him here to the United States while the pandemic is in play.” A Justice Department lawyer, Terry Henry, was quoted as reminding the judge that, by law, the government is forbidden from bringing Guantánamo prisoners to the United States.

At issue is how to balance the insistence of the defense lawyers that they continue to consult with their clients, even as some proceedings are delayed because of the pandemic, and the insistence of the government that 14 of the 40 men held at Guantánamo could disclose classified information if they were allowed routine telephone calls.

Those 14 prisoners were held at secret C.I.A. sites before their transfer to Guantánamo more than a decade ago. The intelligence agencies argue that they continue to know national security secrets, including where they were held and perhaps the identities of their captors. They are only allowed written communications through secure channels with their lawyers when the lawyers are not at Guantánamo.

The other 26 prisoners held at Guantánamo have been able to speak with their lawyers by telephone for years, including throughout the public health crisis.

Lawyers representing the prisoners regularly visit the base during normal times, but those trips came to a halt in March, after the military discontinued its weekly legal shuttles there because of the pandemic and limited travel to essential personnel. The prison also adopted a policy of requiring lawyers to isolate themselves for two weeks on the base, once legal visits are restored.

Among those most directly affected are the five defendants accused of helping plot the Sept. 11 attacks. Prosecutors in that case proposed one-hour weekly video chats between the defendants and their lawyers linking two classified facilities — a teleconference suite at military commissions headquarters in Alexandria, Va., and the courtroom at Camp Justice at Guantánamo.

Gary D. Sowards, the death penalty defense lawyer for Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, who is accused of being the mastermind behind the Sept. 11 attacks, lives in Manhattan and had asked for a monitored phone call on the grounds that it was too dangerous to travel from one virus hot spot, New York City, to another, outside Washington D.C.

The chief war court judge, Col. Douglas K. Watkins, has ordered prosecutors in the Sept. 11 case to explain why the defendants cannot get the same telephone calls as other prisoners.

Only one lawyer in the case has used the war court teleconference facilities. Walter B. Ruiz, the capital defender for Mustafa al Hawsawi, said on Friday that his conversation with his client lasted two hours on Wednesday — with mixed results.

The camera angle made it impossible to see and discuss documents Mr. Hawsawi had at the defense table in front of him, Mr. Ruiz said.

Mr. Ruiz said he and two linguists on their side of the video conference had to huddle — closer than the six-foot distance mandated under social-distancing guidelines — to see and be seen. But the prisoner, he said, “seemed to be in good spirits.”

Mr. Hawsawi appeared on camera in a beige cloth mask, which he removed for the meeting. Soldiers serving as guards wore gloves, masks and plastic face shields.

“The most practical and adequate thing is to go down to the jailhouse and sit down face to face and go over documents,” Mr. Ruiz said. “That is the standard that we should have. But given the circumstances, I like being able to see each other.”


Criminal Justice


Criminal Justice

Criminal Justice
war and conflict reporting


War and Conflict

War and Conflict

Support our work

Your support ensures great journalism and education on underreported and systemic global issues