Story

Smoke and Mirrors: A Broken System

23-bertrams-new.jpg

Kamuzu Central Hospital in Malawi’s capital Lilongwe is one of the few clinics in the country that has a dedicated burns ward. Image by Nathalie Bertrams. Malawi, 2017.

Kamuzu Central Hospital in Malawi’s capital Lilongwe is one of the few clinics in the country that has a dedicated burns ward. Image by Nathalie Bertrams. Malawi, 2017.

Smoke released by cooking in non-ventilated places is one of the world’s leading causes of illness and death.

According to the WHO, it can cause respiratory infections, lung cancer, heart disease and blindness, as well as short term suffering such as coughing, burning eyes, chest pain and headaches.

The prey of the silent killer in the kitchen? The people who spend the most time indoors: in the developing world, mainly women and children.

xMore than half of premature deaths among children under the age of five are due to pneumonia caused by breathing this smoke, and there is evidence of a link between indoor air pollution and low birth weight.

Dr. Wezzie Mumba, Senior Medical Officer at the Bwaila Hospital, Lilongwe – Malawi’s capital city – sees how critical the situation is. "The women who do come to the clinics have severe lung problems," she says. "Problems that usually only chainsmokers have."

Only 0.4 per cent of women in Malawi are smokers – but experts have likened just one hour of cook smoke to burning 400 cigarettes.

24-bertrams-new.jpg

The majority of burn victims in Malawi are under the age of 5. Image by Nathalie Bertrams. Malawi, 2017.

The majority of burn victims in Malawi are under the age of 5. Image by Nathalie Bertrams. Malawi, 2017.

Treating by guesswork

How does Dr. Mumba recognize that the cause might be unclean cooking? "The hairs on their arms are all gone because of the open fire," he says.

Basic health care is free of charge in Malawi, but clinics are understaffed and underfunded: there are only two doctors available per 100,000 patients. Medication is also scarce.

Therefore, says Matron Phirie of Chintheche Rural Hospital in Nkhata Bay district in the north of the country, it is difficult to treat smoke-related diseases. "We are unable to find out the causes – there is not even an x-ray machine in the clinic," she says, adding that health practitioners "just prescribe antibiotics – that is all we have," without really knowing what the underlying illness is.

"We can only treat for chest infections and pneumonia on that presumption. But so many come back and back."

25-bertrams-new.jpg

A lack of data prevents the ‘killer in the kitchen’ making it onto the country’s health agenda. Image by Nathalie Bertrams. Malawi, 2017.

A lack of data prevents the ‘killer in the kitchen’ making it onto the country’s health agenda. Image by Nathalie Bertrams. Malawi, 2017.

Not only do doctors need to know what caused a disease to treat it well, they also need data to measure the scale of the crisis – data that currently does not exist. And not having this data on a hospital or national level is crippling Malawi’s response: where there is no data, there is no information and often no donor funding.

Dr. Mumba believes that most funding is earmarked for the prevention and treatment of HIV/AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis. "That is where the donors give money for."

Even with around 13,000 deaths per year attributed to household air pollution – 8.6 per cent of the country’s deaths – it seems difficult for the ‘killer in the kitchen’ to make it on to the country’s health agenda.